New York Post, {FRONT PAGE} AIDS TOTS USED AS 'GUINEA PIGS'
By DOUGLAS MONTERO
February 29, 2004 -- The state Health Department has
launched a probe into potentially dangerous drug research
conducted on HIV-infected infants and children at a
Manhattan foster-care agency, The Post has learned. Some 50
foster kids were used as "guinea pigs" in 13 experiments
with high doses of AIDS medications at Manhattan's
Incarnation Children's Center, sources said.
Most of the ICC experiments were funded by federal grants
and in some cases, pharmaceutical companies. They used city
foster children, who were sent to the Catholic
Archdiocese-run facility by the Administration for
Children's Services.
ICC was involved in 36 different experiments, according to
the National Institutes of Health Web site. One study
researched "HIV Wasting Syndrome," which studied how a
child's body changes when his medication is altered.
A handful of the experiments involved combining up to six
AIDS drugs - so-called "cocktails" - in children as young as
3 months, and another explores the reaction of not one, but
two doses of the measles vaccine in kids ages 6 to 7 months.
Other studies tested the "safety," "tolerance" and
"toxicity" of AIDS drugs.
"They are torturing these kids, and it is nothing short of
murder," said Michael Ellner, a minister and president of
Health Education AIDS Liaison, an advocacy group for HIV
parents.
Biochemist Dr. David Rasnick, a visiting scholar at the
University of California at Berkeley and an expert in AIDS
medication, was outraged because the drugs, alone or
combined, have "acute toxicity which could be fatal."
He said the drugs' side effects include severe liver damage,
cancerous tumors, severe anemia, muscle wasting, severe and
life-threatening rashes and "buffalo hump," where fatty
tissues accumulate behind the neck.
Housed in a former convent and run by the Archdiocese of New
York's Catholic Charities, the foster-care agency described
the experiments on its own Web site, which was abruptly shut
down after The Post began making inquiries.
Archdiocese spokesman Joseph Zwilling said experiments at
ICC were halted in 2002. He said he did not know why. Zwil-
ling also said he did not know if any children had died.
An ACS spokeswoman said the agency hasn't approved any new
experiments since 2000 because the "risks outweighed the
benefits." She declined to explain further. That agency is
also reviewing its files on the case.
Jacqueline Hoerger was a pediatric nurse at ICC from 1989 to
1993 and said the experimentation was going on even back
then. "We were taught that any symptom we saw was
HIV-related," said Hoerger, 43. "The vomiting, diarrhea,
wasting syndrome, the neurological side effects - they were
dying. There was death."
She didn't think doctors were doing anything wrong, however,
until years later, when she tried to adopt two of the foster
girls. When she refused to give the kids the center's
high-powered AIDS cocktails for fear it was making them
sicker, ACS had social workers take the children away from
her.
Advocates for children question the ethics of experimenting
on foster kids - especially those too young to know what's
happening to them.
"The most vulnerable, disadvantaged children are being
exploited by powerful entities and used as guinea pigs as if
they were not human beings," said Vera Sharav from the
Alliance for Human Research and Protection.
The tests were conducted by doctors from Columbia
Presbyterian Medical Center, which was affiliated with ICC
until 2002 and reaped the financial benefits of the
research.
"Through these trials, children at the ICC outpatient clinic
gained access to state-of-the-art treatments for HIV," said
Annie Bayne, a Columbia spokeswoman.
ACS policy states it seeks parental consent before a child
is enrolled in a study. If the parents cannot be found,
ACS's medical and legal divisions, and its commissioner,
must all approve.
The condition, however, is that the experiment "offer each
participating child a significant potential benefit, a
concomitant minimal risk of injury or harm," ACS spokeswoman
MacLean Guthrie said.
Fire Commissioner Nicholas Scoppetta, who headed ACS at the
time of the experiments, refused comment.
Officials at ICC, which was established in 1989 to house and
care for HIV-infected "boarder babies" left stranded in city
hospitals, refused to talk to The Post.
NEW YORK POST is a registered trademark of NYP Holdings,
Inc. NYPOST.COM, NYPOSTONLINE.COM, and NEWYORKPOST.COM are
trademarks of NYP Holdings, Inc.
Copyright 2003 NYP Holdings, Inc. All rights reserved.
http://nypost.com/news/regionalnews/19320.htm
|